The Legend of Zelda

All trademarks belong to their respective owners.

Rating

Graphics and Sound

Controls

Gameplay

Lasting Appeal

Pioneering Innovation: Consistently pushes boundaries in adventure game design, from open-world concepts to physics-based gameplay.
Masterful World Building: Hyrule is a consistently enchanting and memorable setting, rich in lore and secrets.
Exceptional Puzzle Design: Dungeons and environmental puzzles are ingeniously crafted, rewarding critical thinking.
Timeless Art Direction: Even older games retain charm, while modern titles boast breathtaking aesthetics.
Iconic Music: Koji Kondo’s compositions and subsequent scores are legendary, enhancing atmosphere and emotion.
Compelling Narratives: While often archetypal, the stories are engaging tales of heroism, sacrifice, and destiny.
High Replayability: Especially with the open-ended nature of Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom.
Strong Community: Passionate fanbase that continually explores, debates, and creates content around the games.
Consistent Quality: Very few “bad” games in the mainline series, maintaining a high standard.

Occasional Experimental Missteps: Some games’ core mechanics (e.g., Zelda II‘s combat, Skyward Sword‘s motion controls) were divisive.
Repetitive Structure (Pre-BotW): Older titles sometimes fell into predictable “find item, solve dungeon, beat boss” loops.
Handholding (Earlier Titles): Some games were criticized for excessive tutorials or obvious hints.
Limited Voice Acting (Pre-BotW): Characters communicated primarily through text, which some found dated.
Long Gaps Between Mainline Titles: While ensuring quality, the wait between major releases can be substantial.
Linearity (Pre-BotW): Some felt older 3D games became too linear in their progression.
Durability System (BotW/TotK): Weapon durability, while encouraging experimentation, remains a polarizing feature for some players.